i love this idea! i have had a fairly good experience swapping and such but...there is always that one who doesn't take their swaps seriously and ruins it for other ppl. i'm not saying we have to leave negative comments but for those of us who swap and do so diligently, this would make us all accountable for turning in our swaps and exchanges. i think it would make all users MORE honest. most of the users and swapppers here are very honest but like i've said there is always that one bad apple that ruins it for others!! instead of a system that you leave comments on, you just give stars to. i don't think we need to get petty here and start leaving bad comments, and i don't think that we need to rate our packages, just if we received them or not. i don't think the quality or workmanship is the issue, it's the receiving of items as promised. i also think that most ppl appreciate what they receive they just WANT to receive it!!!
Just my 2 cents!