Very tough choice to make as they both look great to me. Glad you have to make that decision! I do love both those border fabrics and the colors in the quilt in general. Is that a D9P? What a great way to put it together!
Thank you!

. It started as a Dp9 with a few other fabrics. I found it too busy, so swapped out a few of my fabrics, decided to use the lightest colors outside of the center, and sort of morphed my layout into the Falling Charms pattern (from Missouri Star Quilt Co).