Donita--the new store is in Naples! That's about 25 min from me. I think you'd be about an hour or so away. :D When I do a quilt shop run, I love to go to 2 Mennonite shops, and another locally owned (but more expensive) shop. These stores are in Himrod, outside of Penn Yan, and outside of Stanely.
That'd be fun to meet a forum person!!