This thread makes me sad. People who appreciate a quilt should have a quilt made for them. If one is asking if it's a good idea, it is a possibility that it not a good idea. The giver wants to be her efforts to be appreciated and will be hurt if its not. The quilts we make unless a kit are one of a kind, not a dime a dozen. I only make for those who I know like a one of a kind, made with Love.