Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   Main (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/)
-   -   guttermann thread problem? (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/guttermann-thread-problem-t74569.html)

kdid82 11-07-2010 09:10 AM

I have a Bernina machine and have a problem when I use Gutterman and Mettler in both the needle and bobbin, can only use it in one or the other.

Roberta 11-07-2010 09:14 AM

My LQS said I should use only Guttermans thread, I don't. I've bought one spool it sews about the same as my Connecting Threads spools. I have a Janome as well.

nikki128 11-07-2010 09:34 AM

I have a Bernina 1080 and a singer. Both machine's love Gutterman thread. I buy it on sale at Joanne amd use it almost exclusively because of the price. One day I will move to sulky and maderia.

shrabar 11-07-2010 10:13 AM

Terry I notice that you have a designer 1 did you get 2 throat plates with your machine I only got the zigzag plate I am looking for the straight stitch plate. Thanks Shrabar

mindybw 11-07-2010 10:22 AM

A lot of great tips here regarding spool wrap. For finicky thread, I try to make sure the bobbin and top are compatible (same weight or lighter weight bobbin) use a thread stand, or else my home-made thread feeder using a clean empty jar on the floor and a taped paper clip on the machine for an eye, then thread machine normally. I think this lets the thread untwist more, less breaks when sewing.

ORSunshineQuilter 11-07-2010 10:27 AM

Although I have become a Superior thread user, I have used Guterman thread on my Janomes for many years and have never encountered a problem. Usually when someone in a store tells me not to use a thread (if it is one they don't carry), I question their veracity. After all, they want to sell you THEIR brand of thread. I highly recommend Superior threads! Guterman is my #2 favorite

Kathleen charnell 11-07-2010 11:24 AM

I used to use Gutterman a lot, but lately it seems to have a lot of lint in my Bernina. I use M,ettler Aurifil, Superior, Sulky with no problems & hardly any lint

featherweight 11-07-2010 11:34 AM


Originally Posted by shrabar
Terry I notice that you have a designer 1 did you get 2 throat plates with your machine I only got the zigzag plate I am looking for the straight stitch plate. Thanks Shrabar

I bought one on Ebay when I had my Designer 1.

featherweight 11-07-2010 11:36 AM


Originally Posted by mindybw
A lot of great tips here regarding spool wrap. For finicky thread, I try to make sure the bobbin and top are compatible (same weight or lighter weight bobbin) use a thread stand, or else my home-made thread feeder using a clean empty jar on the floor and a taped paper clip on the machine for an eye, then thread machine normally. I think this lets the thread untwist more, less breaks when sewing.

That is what I do with Metalic thread on my embroidery machine. The further away from the thread guide the better it sews.

carhop 11-07-2010 11:36 AM

When I got my first serger and where I got from told my to use only pure cotton thread still use thecotton poly I asked the husquvarna repair man and he said it does not matter what you use just clean the machine often, the women at the shop when you walked in they would snicker in back of their hands and point to the thread and make you feel like you were durt under their feet , I took it to another store after that

MadQuilter 11-07-2010 11:39 AM


Originally Posted by AlwaysQuilting
I just bought a low end Janome for my DGDs Xmas present.
I asked if it likes or dislikes certain threads and the LQS owner said not to use Guttermann thread. She said it's put on the spool wet at the factory which makes it come off the spool with a tighter curve and doesn't feed through the machine as well.
Have any of you noticed this?

I took a class at our local dealer and the teacher said that when this happens to bring the spool back and get a replacement. She did say that it needs to be a full spool though - not a partially used one, lol. (Apparently some people get crafty)

It apparently is noticeable as soon as you start the spool and any reputable store should recognize the problem and replace the bad thread.

Dix 11-07-2010 11:41 AM

I have 2 Janomes and only use Aurifil on them. Does not break or tangle. I have the 6600 proff and the little Janome Silver. Love them both1

quilter on the eastern edge 11-07-2010 12:20 PM

I have never liked Gutermann thread. I just don't like the feel of it and what Nadine said about it being wound on the spool wet may be a possible explanation. I use Metzler (sp?) and have always had very good results.

danade 11-07-2010 12:20 PM

I occasionally use a Bernette 90e for some parts of my projects and it works really well--but has only a horizontal spool pin. Why is this, I wonder--how much more expenive could it be to construct these machines with a spoon pin that hinges vertically as well as horizontally? I doubt there is any answer to this. But does anybody have a recommendation for a thread stand?

I might add that oddly enough, my Juki 98Q hates Superior Thread of all weights. I had to give up on it and go back to C&C.

Dana

featherweight 11-07-2010 12:22 PM


Originally Posted by danade
I occasionally use a Bernette 90e for some parts of my projects and it works really well--but has only a horizontal spool pin. Why is this, I wonder--how much more expenive could it be to construct these machines with a spoon pin that hinges vertically as well as horizontally? I doubt there is any answer to this. But does anybody have a recommendation for a thread stand?

I might add that oddly enough, my Juki 98Q hates Superior Thread of all weights. I had to give up on it and go back to C&C.

Dana

I use the metal thread stand.

watterstide 11-07-2010 12:22 PM

i use all the time Guttermann, i have never had a problem with it..
i use it on my Janome 6600 and the Gem Platinum.

watterstide 11-07-2010 12:37 PM

Very true, and something i learned about a year ago..

http://www.superiorthreads.com/educa...them-different

cones and spools, the difference in the way they unwind,

there is a whole section on thread education. very good info!
there are a few short videos that are interesting to watch and learn!

Reguarding threads and thier costs..
if you calculated the cost per yard. the larger or costly spools or cones would actually not be as bad as you think.it is the initial cost that makes us not want to pay the amount .
i quit using C & C,because the price went up, and the spool or yardage got smaller..(the new dual duty) . they say it was too linty, but i clean my bobbin area after every small project, usually when i change the bobbin thread, i wipe it out,prior to putting in the new bobbin.
I think the fabric is way more linty than the threads. IMHO

Bev 11-07-2010 12:46 PM

I have two Janomes and use Gutterman's on both of them. I've never had even the slightest problem. I'm talking years of use, not just a few weeks. How the heck do people come up with these stories? If I were you, I'd just ignore it. Give your DGD a few spools of different good quality threads and let her decide which she likes best. 8-)

Bev 11-07-2010 12:51 PM


Originally Posted by Candace
I was also told not to use Gutterman by my dealership, as it "supposedly" has gone way down in quality. But, I still use it with no problems. It's not as good as other thread on the market but in a pinch I will buy it and use it. My favorite thread is still Aurifil. And I use that whenever possible.

I remember my dealer told me if I was going to use Gutterman, to make sure it's the one made in Germany and NOT Mexico. He said there is a big difference in quality. I forgot to mention this in my last post. I've never had to search for it though because my Joann's only stocks the German one.
:wink:

Candace 11-07-2010 01:16 PM


Originally Posted by Bev

Originally Posted by Candace
I was also told not to use Gutterman by my dealership, as it "supposedly" has gone way down in quality. But, I still use it with no problems. It's not as good as other thread on the market but in a pinch I will buy it and use it. My favorite thread is still Aurifil. And I use that whenever possible.

I remember my dealer told me if I was going to use Gutterman, to make sure it's the one made in Germany and NOT Mexico. He said there is a big difference in quality. I forgot to mention this in my last post. I've never had to search for it though because my Joann's only stocks the German one.
:wink:

How do you know it's the ones from Germany? What stores sell the ones from Mexico?

TexasSunshine 11-07-2010 01:20 PM

I have always used Gutermann in my older Pfaff, the cheap thread never worked well in it.

butterflies5518 11-07-2010 01:34 PM

I am currently using Gutermann for making yo-yo's for a quilt and even with beeswax find it very frustrating when it breaks when knotting off. Which seems to be about every 4 yo-yo's or less.

kaygee 11-07-2010 02:26 PM

I have noticed when I use Guttermann thread, the thread kind of jumps off the spool like it is getting caught on something. I think it might have something to do the spools being smaller than the reg. spools of thread. Could this be?

auntiehenno 11-07-2010 02:33 PM

Thanks for the infor on guterman Thread. Think I bought a plastic box full of several colors at Joanns, but have onyl used it for hand sewing.

Va Quilter 11-07-2010 03:02 PM

I have a Viking Designer 1, I was told to use Guttermann thread , NEVER to use Coats & Clarks! Have not had any problems with the Guttermann..I see others agree with me too.

nursie76 11-07-2010 03:05 PM

I use Gutterman polyester for everything! Both of my Bernina's like it as well as my Juki and my little Brother. I very rarely have my thread break. In fact I love it so much, my DH bought me a 100 spool assortment at Joanns for Christmas last year.

jemcnutt 11-07-2010 03:09 PM

I bought hand quilting thread - it was unevenly processed - some lengths very thick, some very, very thin. Will never buy it again.

watterstide 11-07-2010 03:10 PM


Originally Posted by nursie76
I use Gutterman polyester for everything! Both of my Bernina's like it as well as my Juki and my little Brother. I very rarely have my thread break. In fact I love it so much, my DH bought me a 100 spool assortment at Joanns for Christmas last year.


WOW! Good for you! nice present!
:thumbup:

Ann K 11-07-2010 03:27 PM

Oh I am so glad you mentioned this as I have the same machine and every once in awhile the thread gets caught up. I thought it was my machine or I might be doing something wrong. Thanks for the info. I'll change threads.

Also I want to add that when I used Guttermann metalic looking thread it started shredding the getting caught up in the feed dogs. Too bad as the thread looked so pretty.

Does anyone know if all metalic's have this problem?

Ann in San Ramon

Gal 11-07-2010 03:29 PM

In my opinion, I have found that sometimes sales people will say anything to get you to buy 'their stuff' Guttermann is a great middle to top thread range in price and quality, I have used it for over 30 years of sewing and in all that time I have had no problems what so ever, I even use their 100% cotton quilting thread to hand quilt my bed quilts with, I have never needed to change to anything else. Just my opinion.

Gal

tjradj 11-07-2010 03:46 PM

Call me a skeptic, but I use Gutermann all the time with no problem.
Personally, I think your LQS owner is trying to sell you some more expensive thread.
The last time I bought 40 wt Sulky, and had to take it off my machine because it kept breaking. It looked beautiful, but was too soft for my freemotion quilting.
Just use what works for you, and let the quilt police go bark up a tree. :P

AlwaysQuilting 11-07-2010 03:55 PM


Originally Posted by tjradj
Just use what works for you, and let the quilt police go bark up a tree. :P

After reading all these messages I agree!

Catlady 11-07-2010 04:02 PM

I use Gutterman most of the time. The only problem I have
with it is that when I finish sewing a seam and cut the thread
it curls around my machines foot. I also like Mettler. My
machine is a Janome 6600. I bought some Aurafil but haven't
used it yet. I clean my machine after every project too.

nursie76 11-07-2010 04:56 PM


Originally Posted by watterstide

Originally Posted by nursie76
I use Gutterman polyester for everything! Both of my Bernina's like it as well as my Juki and my little Brother. I very rarely have my thread break. In fact I love it so much, my DH bought me a 100 spool assortment at Joanns for Christmas last year.


WOW! Good for you! nice present!
:thumbup:

Yep, I was more than a little excited to see that under the tree! :-D

1Blondie 11-07-2010 05:55 PM

I love guttermann thread, its the coats/clarke thread I don't like, I prefer gutterman over anything else never had a problem with it, I usually get it when it is on sale and stock up. I have a Janomme and have no problem using it.

martha jo 11-07-2010 06:18 PM

I was told by the Bernina dealer some time ago to not use Gutterman as it was trash and would not work well with Bernina.

jitkaau 11-07-2010 06:27 PM

I use Gutterman, Sulky, Isofil, Mettler, Coates, Dewhurst, (some of it old, inherited stuff), Signature, Superior threads, Wonderfil, etc etc. They all serve a purpose for different jobs. The only ones to avoid are the hand quilting threads which have a coating on them that interferes with tension discs and the el - cheapo threads that break all of the time.

CLMQuilter 11-07-2010 06:35 PM

I have a Janome machine and I only use gutermann cotton thread and have never had a problem with it at all.

nursie76 11-07-2010 06:45 PM


Originally Posted by martha jo
I was told by the Bernina dealer some time ago to not use Gutterman as it was trash and would not work well with Bernina.

Isn't it funny? My Bernina dealer recommended Gutterman... :shock:

Bottom line, use what your machine likes.

SewOK 11-07-2010 06:55 PM

Some of the Gutterman thread is made in Germany and some of it (Hancock Fabrics) is made in Mexico. Check your spools to see where it is manufactured. The Gutterman made in Mexico is horrible, i.e., frays i the needle breaks, is full of lint) but the Gutterman made in Germany is of high quality and is great. Hancock Fabrics here in Oklahoma City carries the Gutterman made in Mexico and Jo-Ann Fabrics carries the Gutterman made in Germany.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:11 AM.