I vote for the D9P. Love it.

I love having the white broken up in the D9P

Can you mix em up and do both?

Put both of them up somewhere you can see them easily.
Leave the room and get a drink of water, feed the cat and then return.

Stand way back and look at both of them.
Now which one really catches your eye?

That one is what you should do.

I like the disappearing 9 patch. It looks difficult, but it really is simple.

I think the D9P is more interesting pretty colors

love the colours, i would go for the d9p.

D9P

My vote is for the D9P. For any size quilt....
ConnieF

I'm a big fan of D9P without sashing. That being said, I love your color choices and either design would look great.