I'm a big fan of D9P without sashing. That being said, I love your color choices and either design would look great.

I like the D9P, to me it seems to have more movement and life. Plus it on my list of quilts to make.

I like the D9P. More variation in pattern.

I just found this....This is a D{9 patch that I think might work well with your selection of fabrics. Who would have thought you could lay it our to finish up with this pattern.

http://www.joscountryjunction.com/?p=1732

I'm saving it for me. This would be good for theme fabric, which I've been struggling with.

The D9P gets my vote. It always makes a quilt look complex, but hardly takes any more time.

D9P gets my vote

I like the D9P.

Could combine the two...

I like the D9P :-D :-D :-D

I like the D9P.