The first is so stunning and would be a very dramatic top.

The second seems to be floating in a bed of field flowers. Very pretty, softer combination.

I just like the more dramatic top, but both are beautiful.

#1 for sure.

I would love either one - it is so amazing that they look so different when they are the same pattern - art at its finest.

Number 1. Love the red, rusty color and the way the white sets it off.

I love #1 - love the contrast!!!!

I like #1 the best

I like the first one best. Both are very pretty but I like the darker star in the first one

I like the first one, awful orange fabric(your words, not mine) and all,lol!!!

Both are pretty but I would like getting #1 better.

I like 2.