I like the bottom one the best

I like the scrappy version best.

I like the same colors myself.

My favorite is the same color

I like the same color also. Nice fabric choices.

I like the matching colors too. It seems to give more definition to the design

I prefer the scrappy squares as they have more vibrance. The other way looks safe and a bit boring.

I personally prefer #1. It pulls my eye to look at the whole quilt in all directions. Very nice.

Scrappy!

I love the second one same colors.