Both blocks are beautiful to me.

I like #1 the most, I know it means more work, but it is beautiful.

I like them both

Love them all! Love stars anyway. Am now making star blocks for GS a quilt when he graduates in 3 yrs, then his bro the next, along with a GD. GDs will be lots easier to decide on blocks!!!!

I like both... mix it up.

I like the second one. The Tan or Gold colour in the first one spoils my preference.

Your lemoyne stars look nice and neat, but I think your sawtooth with the floral centers look FANTASTIC! # 2 would delinitely get my vote!

The Lemoyne star has my vote. I think that is my favorite star too.

You can not possibly go wrong with these beautiful fabrics and your careful piecing!! I like the first block better and will really like it when you get that great border fabric on it....

1 gets my vote