I really like both versions. In the first, I see it give you opportunity to quilt and showcase the light space. And the second version lends itself to an overall pattern. Very nicely done. I think the first one was my favorite. (A bit more modern for me.) And the second one matches your bedroom beautifully. It really captures a traditional feel. 2 completely different quilts!

I really like the second quilt better. I like the first one too but the second one shows off the fabrics better. The red makes it pop. Great job.

Love the new version and would like to see it again post-quilting.

What a lot of work! However, the new quilt is stunning and a perfect compliment to the bed. Very nice!!!

I sure do like the change! Much more pleasing to the eye. Congratulations on taking all the work to dis-assemble your first version. I like the little touch of red too!

Very beautiful. I love the second one. Great job

The first one is a nice quilt, but the second effort is classy looking.

I agree, both are nice. I was thinking wouldn't it be great to make one of each using the same fabrics (like the pictures) to use on twin beds in the same room.

The second one is definitely more interesting, but both versions are great.

It was worth all the extra work as I like the 2nd version much better also. I too, have done exactly the same thing when I "hated" a quilt top. I ended up taking the whole thing apart to substitute a different colour & was also much more pleased with the results. Great job.

Totally different look.

Wow you nailed that one its gorgeous :)

I think the first one is very nice, but I agree, the second one is the best! Good work!

Love the second one. What a lot of work taking it apart.

I like the second better, too; but it must have been a terrible job tearing the whole thing apart.

I love the second one...

I can just imagine the work in taking apart that quilt....then having the energy, and your wits still intact to reconstruct the new version!
Great going, love the new version!

Yes, this way is much better. Your headboard is lovely.

Both are nice but #2 is a step above!

The second one is definitely prettier! Beautiful!!

Really, really like the second one!

Thank you all again. I can hardly wait to see how hubby quilts it. If our LA ever gets here.

I like the "movement" in that first layout. The second is nice too, I just prefer it the original way. My, what a lot of work that must have been to change it.