If your Sandy's is a Kroger brand store, you might try their deluxe ice cream brands. I am a huge fan of Blue Bell (don't even go there about the recent brouhaha) and not being able to get it here in VA, I have found Kroger's brand to be a close second. I LOVE their peppermint!! If you CAN get it, ask for it to be carried all year; mine responded positively to my request.

Jan in VA

Blue Bell is my favorite, too bad you're deprived. Bryers,Dryers are both very good ice creams. I like anything with chocolate, peanut butter or caramel.
Sharon in Texas

I grew up with Hoods, but cannot get it in Oklahoma. That's back home in Massachusetts. We have Brahms here, and it is terrific!

Years ago I used to be able to get a peanut butter ice cream, Not vanilla with PB cups.
Loved it. I will have to look for this and see what it is. I have lost my taste for ice cream but if this is the one it might come back.

I like Publix brand.....

I love a good pralines n cream. Only found it in Blue Bell but with the scare, I don't know. Not sure if they've come back with the pralines n cream. Made my own one afternoon. Bought a bunch of pralines candy, chopped it up and so good. I like a good toffee and coffee also.

I, too, am a Pralines 'n Cream lover!!!
My all-time favorite for sure!
I buy mine at Baskin Robbins.

I only buy Talenti brand.

I buy PET Ice Cream to me it's the best

My favorite is Tillamook black cherry. Tillamook is my favorite ice cream. I also live in the west.