Cotton VS polyester batting
07-11-2011, 07:09 AM
#1
Super Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Lake Orion, Mich
Posts: 1,630
A dear friend asked me to make a queen sized quilt for him to give his wife for Christmas... but they prefer the "puffier" quilts. I have always used the Warn & White batting which is 100% cotton. It gives nice warmth but isn't "puffy" - in JoAnn's yesterday, I was looking at the "puffy" batting but it is 100% polyester. I was chatting with another quilter there and she said she didn't like the polyester because it doesn't hold up as well and down the road would start bunching up in the quilt. I also noticed it said "quilt 2" - 4 inches". I am going to do a simple block with embroidery in the center block and could STD along the sashing to accomplish the 2" - 4", but my question is - Is it possible to get "puffy" 100% cotton batt? Any suggestions welcome.
07-11-2011, 07:24 AM
#2
Power Poster
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Ontario, Canada
Posts: 17,717
Re the lady who is saying it comes apart, chances are she has quilted it further apart than is appropriate for poly. As you mentioned, the poly has given you a recommended distance.
IMHO if your friends want puffy, poly is the way to go! Take a look at the thread I just started ... poly batting was used, and the quilting does show puffy, but not overpowering.
http://www.quiltingboard.com/t-136789-1.htm
There's a lot of other batting possibilities than cotton or poly, so I'll look to hear what others suggest.
IMHO if your friends want puffy, poly is the way to go! Take a look at the thread I just started ... poly batting was used, and the quilting does show puffy, but not overpowering.
http://www.quiltingboard.com/t-136789-1.htm
There's a lot of other batting possibilities than cotton or poly, so I'll look to hear what others suggest.
07-11-2011, 07:43 AM
#3
Junior Member
Join Date: May 2010
Location: San Dimas CA
Posts: 160
I love "fluffy" quilts (poly inards). When I make quilts, I ask the receiver if they want "fluffy" or "flat" (cotton). Most choose "fluffy", probably cause of the terms I use. I also like poly cause it doesn't shrink and lasts forever.
07-11-2011, 07:45 AM
#4
Power Poster
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Lake Elsinore, CA
Posts: 15,145
Wool might be a good choice. But first I would ask your friend to show you an example of what he means by puffy. He may be thinking more of a comforter than of a quilt. Then show him one of your quilts quilted with W&W or W&N. He may decide he likes that look just fine. Sometimes people have one thing in mind, until they see something else...
07-11-2011, 07:47 AM
#5
Member
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 11
I have used polyster batting for years and love it. It is light weight, warm, and puffy. I've never had any problem with bunching. But, not having a long arm machine, I tie my quilts usually at 5" intervals. So farther intervals might be a problem, Just don't know.
07-11-2011, 08:07 AM
#6
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Sturbridge, Ma
Posts: 3,992
There must be puffyer cotton batting out there but oh what a problem to quilt close though that it would not shift in both use and washing. I don't know where the "advisor" in the store has been. That, to me is not an answer. She must have been quilting 12" apart on her polyester batting or used one that was not made without falling apart. Advice like you got in the store just makes me shake my head.
Cotton will flatten in time just laying on the bed. So the advice you got above about finding out what is meant by "puffy" is a good one. Puffy to you may be different than to him. Then if he wants real puffy consider the difficulty in quilting it if you do use one of the thicker battings which really have to be tied and not quilted.
Cotton will flatten in time just laying on the bed. So the advice you got above about finding out what is meant by "puffy" is a good one. Puffy to you may be different than to him. Then if he wants real puffy consider the difficulty in quilting it if you do use one of the thicker battings which really have to be tied and not quilted.
07-11-2011, 08:22 AM
#7
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Colorado
Posts: 3,536
When I first started quilting I only used poly batting,extra high loft to be exact.
However now I only use the poly batting if/when I make a kids quilt that is going to be drug around.
My all time favorite batting to use now is bamboo I use to buy it at Joann's, but I do not think they are carrying it anymore or at least the two stores that is closest to me.
A couple years ago I received a quilt that was made by a group of ladies I had NEVER met in person, we all know each other online at cafemom quilting group. When I received this quilt I cried, later I was told that they even went so far to find some bamboo batting to use since they knew it was my favorite.
When I make quilts for family or special friends I use the bamboo.
I DO have some non bamboo batting but very little at this time.
However now I only use the poly batting if/when I make a kids quilt that is going to be drug around.
My all time favorite batting to use now is bamboo I use to buy it at Joann's, but I do not think they are carrying it anymore or at least the two stores that is closest to me.
A couple years ago I received a quilt that was made by a group of ladies I had NEVER met in person, we all know each other online at cafemom quilting group. When I received this quilt I cried, later I was told that they even went so far to find some bamboo batting to use since they knew it was my favorite.
When I make quilts for family or special friends I use the bamboo.
I DO have some non bamboo batting but very little at this time.
07-11-2011, 08:22 AM
#8
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Colorado
Posts: 3,536
When I first started quilting I only used poly batting,extra high loft to be exact.
However now I only use the poly batting if/when I make a kids quilt that is going to be drug around.
My all time favorite batting to use now is bamboo I use to buy it at Joann's, but I do not think they are carrying it anymore or at least the two stores that is closest to me.
A couple years ago I received a quilt that was made by a group of ladies I had NEVER met in person, we all know each other online at cafemom quilting group. When I received this quilt I cried, later I was told that they even went so far to find some bamboo batting to use since they knew it was my favorite.
When I make quilts for family or special friends I use the bamboo.
I DO have some non bamboo batting but very little at this time.
However now I only use the poly batting if/when I make a kids quilt that is going to be drug around.
My all time favorite batting to use now is bamboo I use to buy it at Joann's, but I do not think they are carrying it anymore or at least the two stores that is closest to me.
A couple years ago I received a quilt that was made by a group of ladies I had NEVER met in person, we all know each other online at cafemom quilting group. When I received this quilt I cried, later I was told that they even went so far to find some bamboo batting to use since they knew it was my favorite.
When I make quilts for family or special friends I use the bamboo.
I DO have some non bamboo batting but very little at this time.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Donna Mare
Main
31
11-09-2010 01:08 PM
