sinceresissy

I like your color combo just the way it is - no black. It is going to be beautiful and rich looking.

trolleystation

Go for it....................

toverly

Yall are the best! I tried it with the black melons and my DS who is 17, said "Wow". That's a lot from a 17 year old. I'm going to buy black fabric today. I like the idea of dark charcoal also. So we will see what jumps onto the cutting table.

mojo11

Your quilt will be beautiful. I like the black too.

maryellen2u

Sorry, I don't like the black. I think it is the only thing you see, not the gradations and the lovely print. I think it is too heavy. Have your thought about picking up the pale pink from the print? I usually don't jump in on these types of questions and I do like black for some backgrounds but not in this setting. BTW I love your print and gradations. Lovely choice of colors.

captlynhall

I like the first one best. I think it will make a stunning quilt.

Cheshirecatquilter

I think these colors look sumptuous.

ube quilting

This is going to be awesome as it grows. You will start to see the motion in the rings and it will put a smile on your face.

Oh my that is pretty!
peace