I think the black looks great!

I like the black too...but if you are set on the red outer border, maybe use the black as an inner border over the white.

I like black better.

That's exactly what I was thinking...

I like the black the best, and next the third picture.

They both work very nicely. It comes down to who is going to receive it. What would their preference be?

I really like the black. Really makes the rest of the quilt pop.

I think the black i stunning.

I see your quilt inspector crept into the picture---what does he/she think?

I haven't read all the comments, but I would try it without the white inner border. I would try it with the gray in that spot.

bkay