Why does the cotton thread myth continue?
#41
Power Poster
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Lowell, MA
Posts: 14,083
I've use cotton, rayon, polyester, polyester wrapped cotton and monofilament threads in my quilting, depending on what I'm doing at the time, and if the threads match the project. If I don't want my top stitching to show in quilting, I may use a monofilament thread, which is nothing like the monofilament thread that was around when I first started quilting, which was a little like fish line. In the last several years I have done my quilting with rayon thread, mainly because I like the look, as well as the little extra zing it gives my quilts. It is your quilt, you can do whatever you want. The one rule I honor in quilting is that there are no rules.
#42
Junior Member
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: Blue Mountains, Australia.
Posts: 152
I also wonder if the so-called polyester thread wearing out the cotton piecing could be put down to the poor quality of a lot the fabric available today for quilting. Although I'm new to quilting I've been quite surprised at just how thin so-called quality brands like Moda are.
Last edited by Dalronix; 01-26-2014 at 01:41 PM.
#44
Originally Posted by ghostrider
....I don't use poly thread for the same reason I don't use poly batting...I have no desire to use petroleum products in my quilts.
#45
Super Member
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Heart of Colorado's majestic mountains!
Posts: 6,026
Monofilament thread has changed a lot in recent years because people were trying to find a use for it in quilting-mainly to STID around blocks before adding decorative quilting. It was a utility thread. Cotton thread works with the cotton fabric and simply blends into the project. Any of the threads that are not natural fibers will float on your project and lend a decorative look-they do not blend into the fabric as well and that is their intended function. Polyester thread has probably undergone the most change in recent years. However, it is still a petroleum product and will have the same characteristic as it has always had-low heat tolerance. If it does not melt away it will become brittle and break. I would never use rayon thread in anything I wanted to last a long time because it is wood fiber and will deteriorate quite quickly over a period of time-but it is shiny and supple when applied to a quilt. Having a textiles background I would say that the information you get from Superior Threads (Dr. Bob) is very well done and informative. You can rely on it.I realize that he is selling product but I also know that extensive research goes into the products presented. As quilters you choose the quality of fabric and thread you like to use and you get known characteristics from those choices. I personally prefer natural fabrics and threads and I prefer good quality so I won't be disappointed with the result. I like to vary the weights of the threads I use for different looks.
#46
I use whatever I have on hand. And for piecing, I do a lot of shopping at estate sales. You can't beat a grocery bag filled with thread for $5. If it doesn't break and is sound, it's good by me. My quilts hold up just fine and none of them are headed for a show -- just off to people who like to cuddle under them.
#47
I agree with the comments about cotton being easy to work with and able to take heat. I am surprised that no one mentioned that polyester can cut through cotton threads in a sawing effect...over time. All of my quilts are not intended as heirlooms so I use what I feel is best suited for my project.
#49
I like cotton for piecing, but for quilting, I am starting to find that the polyester has a nicer look to it and also doesn't shred like the cottons do. Even with a large needle I was still getting a lot of breakage on sulky and aurifil cotton thread, YLI ha less breakage but was super linty like crazy, polyester is less linty, had no breakage while quilting. I do find for piecing though, I really like how cotton thread lays, but thats just me. I say use whatever one likes
#50
I use whatever I have on hand. And for piecing, I do a lot of shopping at estate sales. You can't beat a grocery bag filled with thread for $5. If it doesn't break and is sound, it's good by me. My quilts hold up just fine and none of them are headed for a show -- just off to people who like to cuddle under them.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post


