pacquilter

2nd one wins my vote!

dd55

i like #2 the best.

mommessy

I vote for #1. Really cheerful!

MdmSew'n'Sew

I like the second layout with one little addition - turn one of the blocks upside down, I did something similar and when I accidently turned one heart in the opposite direction I left it that way and called it "Follow Your Own Heart"

Mkotch

I like all the hearts going in the same direction. How about a very thin sashing?

A1penny

I really like #2 the best, but all are nice. Which ever way you finish it, it will look great when it is done.

tothenci

Thank you! I'll do!

Yooper32

Since my heart has always been mixed up and torn in several directions, I would choose #3.

quilterella

I like #1, which is reasonably close to what I had suggested in your first post. However, it you turn blocks 2,3 &4 in each 4 patch, you would get the pints going north, south, east and west. It wouldn't matter which way the quilt was laid because there would be no wrong way. Again, they are beautiful blocks and can hardly wait to see the finished quilt.

glorcour

# 1 for me - like the fact that it is not directional
Very pretty