Merry Mayhem New Year Day Mystery
#251
Super Member
Join Date: May 2013
Location: Ballwin, MO
Posts: 4,211
So, finding an alternative E1 fabric for the 38 squares was harder than I anticipated. I have two options that I can see.
The first photo shows, from top, my border fabric A, underneath that are the E1 fabric I was going to use for the 38 squares, along with my D fabric of the same pattern. Underneath those are the E1 fabric I'll be using in the rest of the quilt, plus my E2; underneath those are the stash fabrics I think are tonally compatible. There isn't enough of either of the lighter ones to use alone, so I would have to use them both, or use all three for a scrappy look.
In the next photo, I've changed the three scrappy blues for a lighter blue that I have enough of for the 38 squares, but it has a brighter look than the rest of the fabric line and it's a light, not a medium.
Any thoughts?
The first photo shows, from top, my border fabric A, underneath that are the E1 fabric I was going to use for the 38 squares, along with my D fabric of the same pattern. Underneath those are the E1 fabric I'll be using in the rest of the quilt, plus my E2; underneath those are the stash fabrics I think are tonally compatible. There isn't enough of either of the lighter ones to use alone, so I would have to use them both, or use all three for a scrappy look.
In the next photo, I've changed the three scrappy blues for a lighter blue that I have enough of for the 38 squares, but it has a brighter look than the rest of the fabric line and it's a light, not a medium.
Any thoughts?
Last edited by joe'smom; 12-25-2020 at 12:01 PM. Reason: add comment
#252
Member
Join Date: Oct 2012
Posts: 13
joe'smom, I like the look of photo 1 better. I think I understand everything above the bottom row. I don't think having an E1 and a D of the same pattern is a problem. I like all the fabric choices, including the two different lighter blues for E1 and E2. But I'm not sure what the bottom row is. Do you have enough of the first two light blues?
#253
Super Member
Join Date: May 2013
Location: Ballwin, MO
Posts: 4,211
Thanks, shazziny! The bottom row were the only blues I have that I felt were tonally compatible with the top two rows.
Yes, I would have enough of the upper row lighter blues if I used the blue that is the same pattern as my D for the 38 squares. I didn't care for that idea at first, but maybe I will warm to it. Right now my cutting table is covered with the Bonnie Hunter mystery, so I don't need to make a decision today.
My current inclination is to use the darkest print in the bottom row, which is the one I have enough of to cut three 2 7/8" strips from. My reasoning is, I think it's the most compatible of the three, it looks nice with my D fabric, it will give good contrast in the HSTs, and it is easily distinguishable from my E2, should that come into play later on.
Yes, I would have enough of the upper row lighter blues if I used the blue that is the same pattern as my D for the 38 squares. I didn't care for that idea at first, but maybe I will warm to it. Right now my cutting table is covered with the Bonnie Hunter mystery, so I don't need to make a decision today.
My current inclination is to use the darkest print in the bottom row, which is the one I have enough of to cut three 2 7/8" strips from. My reasoning is, I think it's the most compatible of the three, it looks nice with my D fabric, it will give good contrast in the HSTs, and it is easily distinguishable from my E2, should that come into play later on.
#254
Member
Join Date: Oct 2012
Posts: 13
My current inclination is to use the darkest print in the bottom row, which is the one I have enough of to cut three 2 7/8" strips from. My reasoning is, I think it's the most compatible of the three, it looks nice with my D fabric, it will give good contrast in the HSTs, and it is easily distinguishable from my E2, should that come into play later on.[/QUOTE]
That is the one on the right in the bottom row, right? I think that would look very good for the reasons you give. I agree it's the most compatible, and it really goes with your A fabric so the border will work well. The only possible problem I see has to do with the suggested requirements for the E1 fabric. That it should be a tonal, and darker than E2. I have no idea if that could be a problem. My own E1 is lighter than E2, but it has cranes and flowers on waves, not exactly a tonal. I think it's probably best to go with the fabrics you like.
That is the one on the right in the bottom row, right? I think that would look very good for the reasons you give. I agree it's the most compatible, and it really goes with your A fabric so the border will work well. The only possible problem I see has to do with the suggested requirements for the E1 fabric. That it should be a tonal, and darker than E2. I have no idea if that could be a problem. My own E1 is lighter than E2, but it has cranes and flowers on waves, not exactly a tonal. I think it's probably best to go with the fabrics you like.
#255
I like the lighter blue, joes’smom...I think it makes all the beautiful florals really pop in contrast. Will be so pretty...
After dinner and all the family phone calls out of the way, Hubbie turned on Football....NOT! So, off I went to sewing room...lol. My 2” HST’s are done and I’m about halfway on the 2 1/2” HST’s. Just trimming is needed.. I’ll finish those up tomorrow then..I’m ripping down Christmas. It’s been up since Thanksgiving so I’m ready for normal. I’ll leave outside decor up until after New Years. Anyone else get sick of Christmas decor after awhile? I love setting it up my home for Christmas and I love all the fairy lights on all the time but....ready for normalcy.
After dinner and all the family phone calls out of the way, Hubbie turned on Football....NOT! So, off I went to sewing room...lol. My 2” HST’s are done and I’m about halfway on the 2 1/2” HST’s. Just trimming is needed.. I’ll finish those up tomorrow then..I’m ripping down Christmas. It’s been up since Thanksgiving so I’m ready for normal. I’ll leave outside decor up until after New Years. Anyone else get sick of Christmas decor after awhile? I love setting it up my home for Christmas and I love all the fairy lights on all the time but....ready for normalcy.
#256
joe'smom, I'm not keen on that light fabric in the second picture. It doesn't look nearly as nice as what you have going on in the first picture. My family time is done, so I'm going to move on to the Christmas clue! Fun to have some sewing to do, and be done with the wondering if my fabrics will look good. To the point where I think 'Just go for it' now.
#257
My machine and all my sewing stuff is put away while my family are here. So glad to get a sewing clue, finally. I bought my daughter a portable Juki sewing machine for Christmas, and she wants to set it up and try it tomorrow, so maybe I’ll let her sew my HSTs from clue 2.
Hope you all had a nice Christmas. We did, but I’ve been hopping for two days! I’m glad there are leftovers to eat tomorrow so we can all rest and enjoy each other.
Hope you all had a nice Christmas. We did, but I’ve been hopping for two days! I’m glad there are leftovers to eat tomorrow so we can all rest and enjoy each other.
#260
I After dinner and all the family phone calls out of the way, Hubbie turned on Football....NOT! So, off I went to sewing room...lol. My 2” HST’s are done and I’m about halfway on the 2 1/2” HST’s. Just trimming is needed.. I’ll finish those up tomorrow then..I’m ripping down Christmas. It’s been up since Thanksgiving so I’m ready for normal. IAnyone else get sick of Christmas decor after awhile? I love setting it up my home for Christmas and I love all the fairy lights on all the time but....ready for normalcy.
I will be working on organizing my sewing room over the next couple of days now that I’m all caught up. I purchased two IKEA drawer units last weekend and DH put them together for me. They fit nicely under my cutting table. Hope everyone had a wonderful Christmas.