Round Robin help - I'm stumped for an idea!
02-10-2013, 08:32 AM
#94
Super Member
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: kansas
Posts: 6,407
Originally Posted by Jan in VA
I've had a couple of Aha! moments after reading these next pages of ideas and am feeling more encouraged! Keep them coming, please!
As much as I want to, I feel I can't remove the work of the round 2 quilter who added these two wonky borders.
It is SO unlike her usual work....her own quilt for round robin has a lovely, well-pieced mariner's compass in the center!! The man to whom this wonky one belongs created darling, colorful, striped beach umbrellas for his round on this woman's quilt ....so unfair for him to get this from her.
My heart keeps telling me to email him with a picture of her round, which I believe he has already seen, and ask his desire for me to do in mine round for him. I'm also thinking of piecing borders such as have been suggested here, but not attaching them to the quilt, so that HE can decide how he wants to handle it.
Of course, then I have no idea how it will appear when we all stand before the guild next month to show off this round's work on the quilts we had. I'll look like a idiot for not finishing, I suppose, though that doesn't necessarily bother me....I know my heart so I rarely worry about the opinion of others in cases like this. But, I'm just sort of worried that others will realize there wasn't anything I could do about her work and will talk about her. Such a dilemma!!
Jan in VA
As much as I want to, I feel I can't remove the work of the round 2 quilter who added these two wonky borders.
It is SO unlike her usual work....her own quilt for round robin has a lovely, well-pieced mariner's compass in the center!! The man to whom this wonky one belongs created darling, colorful, striped beach umbrellas for his round on this woman's quilt ....so unfair for him to get this from her.
My heart keeps telling me to email him with a picture of her round, which I believe he has already seen, and ask his desire for me to do in mine round for him. I'm also thinking of piecing borders such as have been suggested here, but not attaching them to the quilt, so that HE can decide how he wants to handle it.
Of course, then I have no idea how it will appear when we all stand before the guild next month to show off this round's work on the quilts we had. I'll look like a idiot for not finishing, I suppose, though that doesn't necessarily bother me....I know my heart so I rarely worry about the opinion of others in cases like this. But, I'm just sort of worried that others will realize there wasn't anything I could do about her work and will talk about her. Such a dilemma!!
Jan in VA
02-10-2013, 09:04 AM
#95
Super Member
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Springville, Tennessee
Posts: 1,123
I am sorry that someone ruined a beautiful beginning. I am sorry you have to find a way to save this. I like KarenK's idea the best, but that may be because she made it visual. Good luck and am anxious to hear and see the conclusion to this story. Also, if this was to happen to anyone, Jan you are the one - you are so far ahead of the rest of us!
02-10-2013, 06:52 PM
#96
Super Member
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Lumby, British Columbia
Posts: 2,769
Geez Jan this is quite a pickle. In my own humble opinion ( and since you asked), I think this quilt has enough going on. What about a red border either using a square in a square border, or large flying geese that are edge. I mean the geese pare on their sides? Does this make sense? Plain would work as well.
02-10-2013, 06:57 PM
#97
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2011
Posts: 506
I would put a red border about 1 1/2 to 2" then put our beautiful work eveyone on here will know your work and your guild will know also ,I know your round robin ,you can't take hers off or add to it in any way sorry DottieBug
02-10-2013, 07:22 PM
#98
Super Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Piedmont Virginia in the Foothills of the Blue Ridge Mtns.
Posts: 8,562
You all have been so precious to help with suggestions and give your compliments for my ability to figure this out (that's a pretty high pedestal, guys, and I'm not the fond of heights with edges!!). I DID email the quilt owner with the picture of what I have to work on, and the 3 graphics sent to the thread, and asked him what he wanted me to do. It was a lengthy email, whining about how much I disliked what I'd been left with and how worried I was about his happiness with the finished quilt.
Being a guy, he sent back a terse one liner saying he liked the one with red that appears to wrap around itself....the graphic eparys first sent back on page 1. That, of course, didn't really tell me a dang thing!! Do I leave hers? Do I make the 'wrap' border but leave it unattached so he can do it later? Does he want it in only red, then? MEN!
And I still don't have the quilt to begin work on it; got to call and push the round 4 gal tomorrow; enough delay is enough already.
I will try to get a photo before I take it to guild meeting on March 1 so you can see how I finally rid myself of this albatross.
Jan in VA
Being a guy, he sent back a terse one liner saying he liked the one with red that appears to wrap around itself....the graphic eparys first sent back on page 1. That, of course, didn't really tell me a dang thing!! Do I leave hers? Do I make the 'wrap' border but leave it unattached so he can do it later? Does he want it in only red, then? MEN!
And I still don't have the quilt to begin work on it; got to call and push the round 4 gal tomorrow; enough delay is enough already.
I will try to get a photo before I take it to guild meeting on March 1 so you can see how I finally rid myself of this albatross.
Jan in VA
02-13-2013, 06:45 PM
#100
Junior Member
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Michigan
Posts: 280
Yikes! I know I'm a newbie but I thought you had laid the round robin quilt on top of something you were working on. Didn't realize till I was reading replies that that was part of the quilt - ouch. Will be interested to see what you come up with.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
mary quite contrary
Pictures
196
11-16-2012 09:47 AM
jstitch
Main
543
07-02-2010 05:26 AM
JANW
Member Swaps and Round/Row Robins
305
07-15-2009 12:13 AM
