dunngriffith

I used to show livestock and I had champion stock. But at this one show I kept getting put at the end of the line- last! Months later I was visiting with the judge of that show and he made the comment "I didn't know who you were" Thats why he put my animal down- He didn't know who I was!!!!! That should not have made any difference.
I don't know how quilt shows go but I do know there is a lot of politics involved it most types of shows.
Sorry for your experience. Smile and keep trying! You're good.

ghostrider

Art quilts are judged on the same criteria as traditional quilts...quality of workmanship in binding, stitching, piecing; overall use of color and materials; that kind of thing.

Art quilts are not judged on choice of pattern any more than traditional quilts are. It's all about execution and the choices the quilter made during construction.

meemersmom

I have entered shows before. Won some and lost some. All were learning experiences that I wouldn't trade for anything. Take the judges' words to heart -- it is meant as constructive criticism. Learn from it and improve from it. Although the critique may be harsh, we all ask for it by entering our quilts in shows, and shouldn't complain too loudly when we get what we ask for.

Bobbielinks

Yes, it is hard to accept criticism. Especially shen we have put a lot of time and love into a project. However, we do get over it, look back, and learn from that experience. I very sorry that you are going through this, but in looking at your avatar, you do beautiful work. So hang in there and continue doing what you love.

BellaBoo

The quilt judges uses for the area fair always checks the binding on the quilt first thing. If the binding is good then they look at the rest of the quilt. Bad binding, it is automatically out of the blue ribbon category.

maryb119

Don't let a judges comments upset you. Just remember that it is only one persons opinion and the opinion that really counts is yours. If you are happy with your quilts, that is all that matters.

YolandaW

Let me share with you an experience I had years ago, not with quilts but with dogs. I showed dogs for 20 years and always entered AKC shows. At this one show I was so embarrassed because this judge pulled me out of line and put me out front and proceeded to tell the other exhibitors to look at how great my dog was. That THAT was what this breed should look like, blah blah blah...welllllll...she had me go back and join the line and proceeded to give the wins to the OTHER dogs in the ring...WHAT? WHAT? NOW that was humiliation. lol..Actually after we exited the others came up to me and were saying how crazy that was. lol...needless to say I never ever entered under that judge again...go figure

MsEithne

ROFLMAO!

At one show, my breed was first in the ring that day. My male lost to another dog that he'd beaten several times already. Fair enough, everyone has good days and bad days, no one in dogs ever agrees on everything, etc. I've never complained about a loss and I wasn't about to start then.

But as I hung out ringside, I noticed that the judge had each class go in catalog order and he placed in catalog order, too. Out of the six or seven breeds I watched, not once did he deviate from catalog order: first dog in the ring always got first, etc. Just seemed really strange.

Later, a friend of mine who belonged to the club putting on the show called me. She'd been talking to the woman who drove that judge to the show and the woman had thanked her profusely for the club's courtesy to her friend, the judge. It turns out that the judge was losing his eyesight to diabetes and this was probably his last assignment because he wasn't getting any offers (imagine that).

I roared with laughter! My dog really *WAS* judged by a (legally) blind judge!

My boy finished the next day but I think the day before was a lot more memorable. I still giggle out loud when I think of that day.

lalaland

I don't mind constructive criticism but any criticism should be tempered with some kind of praise. You can always find something nice to say no matter what the project. Did they have a suggestion box? Might be worth a try to submit your own construction criticism of their judging comments.

LivelyLady

A friend of mine entered a quilt at the County Fair. She didn't win a ribbon but wasn't disappointed for that reason; she was disappointed that there was no comment nor critique to let her know what she needed to improve on in the future. I thought that very unprofessional on the judges part :thumbdown: