denilynne

I was really shocked, she probably already has a contract though, she has the best voice but she doesn't really have any stage presents. but i love her, i'm voting for scottie and lauren and i really like haley, the guys can go home. Just my opinion

polly13

I have stopped watching since I became so frustrated with the public votes. They certainly don't vote based on talent. I wish they would have professional judges make the decision. Probably the public wouldn't watch without the input.

mexmmh43

My DH and I have been saying all along that its the teeny bopper girls that vote and they vote for the cutiest boy not the most telanted. That is to bad. love love love Scotty his voice send chills up my spine. This the most telanted group I have seen since I started watching 3 years ago.

linken

It's all in the votes!. I watch it, but can't vote.

tutty

Yep but remember Jennifer Hudson ?!!!!!!!!

sandpat

I keep telling DH that its the little teenage girls doing all the voting, so we'll never understand what is going on in their heads..:roll: I generally never agree with the winner and usually not the runner up either. Except for Carrie Underwood, I think that the rest of the Idol group that has done well were not winners of the show. Its a great jumping off start for them though..no matter! Sad to see Pia go though.

christinetindell

I agree, I think she is the next Jennifer Hudson. She is incredible vocally and last night because she was fighting off tears, her voice cracked, otherwise I thought she was incredible. The year Jennifer Hudson was on was the same year as Latoya London and I thought she was great. I quit watching after she was voted off, but I can't say the same for this year. I am rooting for Casey, Paul and the black dude...sorry, can't remember his name. He seems really genuine and I think Casey is a musical genius but maybe Idol isn't the right venue for him. Paul is also musically pure and his smile and stage presence is absolutely infectious. I think the gal from Georgia is way too young and this fame will destroy her.

fivepaws

We used to watch religiously several years ago. As long as it was a talent show, it was great but when it was thrown out to the audience and beccame a popularity contest------That was it for us.

Stitchit123

I don't watch any of the talent or so called reality shows but I turned the tv on to watch Bones caught the worst rendition of Stand By You I've ever heard that girls voice set my dog to howling and my fixed but still in heat cat joined in the critters carried the tune much better if thats the winner how bad were the non-winners?

Owllady

I really thought it would be Pia and Scotty in the final two. Guess this old person does not see things like the younger generation.